got attached to the boy in chapter 1, he died by the end of chapter 1. Its been 5 days and i still cry for that boy. Idk wtf is wrong with me. I cant keep reading because it just hurts. But it looks like a good story so i give it a 10/10.

I’d rate this 10000/10 if it weren’t for the modern arc.. If I were to rate the modern arc it would be 7

completed: I love this series sm. After modern arc ended(I'm still not fond of this arc) I thought future arc was weird. I didn't think I'd like it, but deeper into the arc I loved it. It didn't have annoying hayase descendants. #32 is my favorite hayase, dethroning kahaku. Heck she's not even considered a hayase at this point. She's a different character with a complex backstory (which was heartwrenching) she's not annoying and she's incredibly likeable. She's basically the protagonist in the future arc.

Overall I loved this series. I just randomly stumbled upon the first episode of the anime and it changed me. I had to read the manga and ts destroyed me, it made me cry so many times. I still think Past arc is the best. Where we get introduced and get attached to the characters.

Hoping s2 will be good and cut off unnecessary parts. Hell, modern arc is annoyingly long. I'll miss this series.

The only downside is the part in modern arc where The nokker who possessed mimori is a fuckin pervert and extremely annoying too. I'm glad she's gone tho, that's a really major turn off in this manga but all in all, it's a masterpiece

I’ve followed this manga since the day chapter 1 released. The very beginning of this series is a masterpiece. The first two volumes are my absolute favourite... but the story eventually takes a turn I wasn't a fan of.

As the plot progressed, it transformed into a series that just isn't for me.
I lost interest in the characters and their journey around the modern arc, but I’ll be back to see how things turn out when the story as a whole is completed!

while I don't always understand Ooima Yoshitoki’s creative decisions, I've seen few other series unravel in such surprising ways! Me dipping out doesn't mean others wouldn't love it all as much as I wish I could have. Defininatly a gem.

it is interesting and its pretty good for what it is...
however this is far too depressing for me...
this should carry the tag psycological horror too, there is too much death and suffering with nothing to balance it out.

so if you have depression (even if it is under control) you might want to skip this one.

Veery good but the modern arc is taking away points for me

Honestly I loved everything about this Manga until the modern arc (ch117). It feels SO BORING reading the new modern arc. I recommend reading it to the chapter 116. Also why is the author even writing and showing a pedophile person if it doesn't even influence the story... 😶 Is that really necessary?? This Manga really went downhill and should've ended at chapter 116 if the story's going to be about romance and weird stuff I miss when this Manga had sense and when it wasn't boring asf. I'd give 9 stars before the modern arc and 4 stars for the new modern arc (after ch 116). The new cyberpunk arc is confusing but it's a little better

First half was super good with a strong emotional beginning. 2nd half got kinda weird.

WAHH IT'S SO GOOD~ i've read this years ago and still waiting for updates up till now.. most definitely, when i have my own money i want to buy hard copies of all the volumes of this manga (*TーT)b

the anime version is so good